Starbucks toffee nut vs. hazelnut syrup: Which one tastes better?

Pairing a drink with the right syrup is often challenging for most new Starbucks customers. I can relate since the first time I wanted to try syrup, I did not know which one to order with my beverage.

I found the long list of syrups at Starbucks quite confusing and therefore started researching more about it. This compelled me to create a post to help you learn more about syrups like toffee nut and hazelnut. By the end of this post, you will also discover which one tastes better. Enjoy!

What are the differences between Starbucks toffee nut vs. hazelnut syrup?


Toffee nut syrup

Hazelnut syrup


Salt, water, sugar, natural flavor, citric acid, and potassium sorbate

Citric acid, natural flavor, sugar, water, and potassium sorbate

Taste profile

Rich, nutty, and buttery flavor

It is nutty and subtle

Caffeine content/ Nutritional value

No caffeine

A serving of this has 70 calories, 17 grams of carbs, and 16 grams of sugars

No caffeine

A serving of this contains only 20 calories. 12 servings of this contains 80 calories, 20 grams of sugar, and 6 mg of potassium

Availability/ Accessibility

Not easy to access

Not easy to access

Starbucks toffee nut vs hazelnut syrup – How They Compare.

Starbucks toffee nut vs. hazelnut syrup

What it’s made of (ingredients).

Hazelnut syrup contains sugar, water, citric acid, potassium sorbate, and natural flavor. On the other hand, toffee nut syrup has salt, water, sugar, citric acid, natural flavor, and potassium sorbate. Though both syrups seem to have similar ingredients, the syrups are not the same.

In terms of ingredients, toffee nut and hazelnut syrup draw in this category.

Taste profile

Toffee nut syrup has a rich nutty, and buttery flavor due to its toffee element. On the other hand, Starbucks hazelnut syrup has a subtle nutty taste. Some customers, however, don’t like Starbucks hazelnut syrup since they reveal that it sometimes tastes like it is watered down.

Starbucks toffee nut syrup wins in this category since it has a better taste.

Caffeine content/nutritional value

Starbucks toffee nut syrup and hazelnut syrup do not contain any caffeine, but you can use them in caffeinated drinks. A serving of Starbucks toffee nut syrup contains 70 calories, 125 mg of sodium, 16 grams of sugar, and 17 grams of carbs.

A bottle of hazelnut syrup contains 80 calories, 6 mg of potassium, and 20 grams of sugar. The bottle contains 12 servings of this syrup. A serving of this syrup has only 20 calories.

Starbucks hazelnut syrup, therefore, wins in this category since it has fewer calories than toffee nut syrup.

Availability/ Accessibility

Starbucks toffee nut syrup and hazelnut syrup are sometimes hard to access from Starbucks stores due to a shortage of some ingredients. You can, however, buy them online.

Toffee nut syrup and hazelnut syrup draw in this category since they are both hard to access.

Starbucks toffee nut vs. hazelnut syrup: A comparison overview

Starbucks toffee nut syrup – Overview

Starbucks toffee nut

If you are looking for a good syrup that you can add to an ice coffee or latte, you should consider Starbucks toffee nut since it can make it more delicious by giving it a nutty flavor. This syrup is popular for its buttery and rich flavor. Toffee nut refers to a blend of roasted nuts and chewy toffee, which creates a unique flavor.

Starbucks was one of the first coffee houses to introduce toffee nut syrup, and it did not take long to gain traction among its customers. During the holidays, this company keeps introducing different toffee nut flavored beverages you can try. Many people like it since its sweet flavor is not overwhelming. Due to the flavor of this syrup, it goes well with bitter beverages. This syrup is clear, golden-hued, and thick.

What I liked

  • It is sweet and buttery

What I didn’t like;

  • It is not always available at Starbucks

Who it’s best suited for

  • Best for people who enjoy a nutty flavor

Starbucks hazelnut syrup- Overview

hazelnut syrup

If you would like to enhance the taste of a hot latte, you can do this by adding Starbuck hazelnut syrup. This is made up of sugar, water, potassium sorbate, and citric acid. Though some people often assume that this syrup contains real hazelnuts, it does not. It is its natural flavor that gives it the hazelnut taste. This syrup does not also contain any nuts.

This naturally flavored syrup can add a personal touch to different drinks like macchiato, iced coffee, hot chocolate, and milkshakes. It also pairs well with non-dairy milk alternatives such as coconut milk.

Unfortunately, getting this syrup from Starbucks is sometimes hard since the company has been experiencing a shortage in some of its ingredients. If you like it but fail to get it at Starbucks, you can try looking for it from online sources such as Amazon.

What I liked

  • It has a nice smell

What I didn’t like

  • Unavailability at most Starbucks stores

Who it’s best suited for

  • Coffee lovers looking for a low-calorie syrup

Final Verdict: So, Which is Better? – Starbucks toffee nut vs. hazelnut syrup

Starbucks toffee nut syrup is better since it has a better taste than hazelnut syrup. Many Starbucks customers like the rich and buttery flavor of toffee nut syrup and find the taste of hazelnut syrup watered down. Toffee nut syrup is a nice complement to coffee drinks. However, you should add toffee nut syrup in small amounts to avoid over sweetening your drink and taking in a lot of calories. I ,therefore, choose Starbucks toffee nut syrup as the clear winner.


Is Starbucks hazelnut sweeter than toffee nut syrup?

No. Toffee nut syrup is sweeter since hazelnut syrup is subtle and watered down.

Which has a better flavor between toffee nut syrup and hazelnut syrup?

Toffee nut syrup has a better flavor than hazelnut syrup

Which one is more suitable for cold coffees between hazelnut syrup and toffee nut syrup?

Hazelnut syrup pairs well with cold coffees.

Leave a Comment