Starbucks Creme Frappuccino Vs Coffee Frappuccino: Which one is better?

Most people always grab a Frappuccino drink whenever they want something sweet, refreshing, and cold. My favorite is Caramel Ribbon Crunch Frappuccino, a mixture of caramel syrup with milk, coffee, and ice, topped with caramel drizzle, whipped cream, and crunch caramel sugar topping, making it incredibly delicious and satisfying. There is a wide variety of Frappuccino blended beverages at Starbucks, with coffee and crème Frappuccinos having different options. Since I love Frappuccinos, I decided to try the Frappuccino blended drinks to determine which, between coffee and crème Frappuccino, is better. After extensive research and personal experience, I have created this article to help you learn how the two Frappes differ.

What are the differences between Starbucks Creme Frappuccino Vs Coffee Frappuccino?

Feature/Coffee	Starbucks Creme Frappuccino	Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino
Ingredient	Ice, Milk, Crème Frappuccino Syrup, Whipped Cream Selected flavor (mocha, caramel, vanilla, or strawberry)	Ice, Milk, Coffee Frappuccino Syrup Whipped Cream Selected flavor (mocha, caramel, vanilla, or strawberry)
Taste Profile	Taste depends on the blended, flavor and topping options you choose during customization	Taste depends on the blended, flavor and topping options you choose during customization
Calories	Ranges from 210 to 480	Ranges from 380 to 460
Sugar Content	Ranges from 46 to 61 grams	Ranges from 42 to 64 grams
Fat Content	Ranges from 16 to 25 grams	Ranges from 2.5 to 24 grams
Caffeine Content	Ranges from 0 to 70 milligrams	Ranges from 85 to 155 milligrams
Availability	Available throughout the year with the exceptional of seasonal options such as the Strawberry Crème Frappuccino.	Available throughout the year with the exception of Seasonal options such as Mocha Cookie Crumble Frappuccino.
Roast Level	Does not contain coffee	Frappuccino roast-a strong/light roast

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino Vs Coffee Frappuccino – How They Compare

Ingredient

Starbucks often describes its beverages in terms of their ingredients. The ingredients impact a drink’s taste and nutritional value. 

When preparing a Starbucks Creme Frappuccino, your preferred blended option and flavor (mocha, caramel, vanilla, brown sugar, cinnamon dolce, toffee nut, hazelnut, or strawberry syrup) is combined with milk and ice; the barista tops the blend with whipped cream and other toppings you may choose to add. 

Conversely, when preparing a Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino, the barista blends your favorite espresso and shot, blended and flavor (mocha, caramel, vanilla, brown sugar, cinnamon dolce, toffee nut, hazelnut, or strawberry syrup) options with milk and ice; he then adds whipped cream and other optional toppings. 

Though the difference between the two coffee houses is minimal, the Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house wins since drinks in this category contain coffee, which will help keep you awake for extended periods. 

Taste Profile

Taste is a major determinant of a customer’s choice of a drink. For both drinks, taste depends on the blended, flavor, and topping options you choose during customization. 

The blended, flavor and topping options are the same for both drinks, making it hard to choose between them. 

Calories

Calorific value is one of the most crucial nutritional information when choosing which drink to order. 

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks have a calorific value ranging from 210 to 480. On the other hand, Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages have a calorific value ranging from 380 to 460. 

The median average calorific value for Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks is 345, while that of the Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages is 420. 

For a person wishing to limit their daily calorie intake to the recommended value (2000 calories per day), taking a Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house beverage is better than taking a Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverage.

Sugar Content

Sugar content is at the top of the list of the factors that customer considers when choosing which drink to order at Starbucks.

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks have a sugar content ranging from 46 to 61. On the other hand, Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages have a sugar content ranging from 42 to 64.

The median average sugar content for Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks is 53.5, while that of the Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages is 53.

Therefore, the drinks in both coffee houses are almost the same in their sugar content which is evident in the 0.5 difference in their median average. 

Fat Content

Fat content is also at the top of the factors that customer considers when choosing which drink to order at Starbucks.

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks have a fat content ranging from 16 to 25. On the other hand, Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages have a fat content ranging from 2.5 to 24.

The median average fat content for Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks is 20.5, while that of the Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages is 13.25.

Therefore, Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages win in this category because their low median average fat content makes them heart-friendly and good for persons on a weight loss mission. 

Caffeine Content

Caffeine content is a major factor when choosing which drink to order at Starbucks.

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks have a caffeine content ranging from 0 to 70. On the other hand, Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages have a caffeine content ranging from 85 to 155.

The median average caffeine content for Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks is 35, while that of the Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages is 120.

Therefore, the Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house wins if you are a caffeine lover since drinks in this category have more caffeine.

Availability

Most Starbucks Creme Frappuccino and Coffee Frappuccino house drinks are available all year round. 

There is no winner in this category since it is easy to access a majority of Starbucks Creme Frappuccino and Coffee Frappuccino house drinks all year round except for seasonal options in both houses. 

Roast Level 

A coffee roast can be light, medium, or dark; Light coffee roasts are the strongest. Starbucks Creme Frappuccino house drinks have no coffee content. On the other hand, Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house beverages contain Frappuccino roast, which is a strong roast. 

The Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino house drinks win easily in this category because they contain a light roast coffee, making them strong coffees. 

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino Vs. Coffee Frappuccino: A comparison review

Starbucks Creme Frappuccino-Overview

You are missing out if you have not had a Starbucks Creme Frappuccino. The flavors of the Crème Frappuccino Syrup blend well with your favorite blended, flavors (mocha, caramel, vanilla, brown sugar, cinnamon dolce, toffee nut, hazelnut, or strawberry syrup) and topping options to create an unforgettable sweet taste. 

What I liked;

• Rich flavor 
• Delicious 

What I didn’t like;

• Some of the Creme Frappuccino house drinks are seasonal.  

Who it’s best suited for.

• Best suited for persons with a sweet tooth. 

Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino-Overview 

The drink is the perfect option for you if you crave a sweet and caffeinated drink. The flavors of a shot of espresso blend perfectly with your favorite blended, flavors (mocha, caramel, vanilla, brown sugar, cinnamon dolce, toffee nut, hazelnut, or strawberry syrup) and topping options to give you a drink that will leave you wanting more.  

What I liked;

• Delicious 
• A relatively high caffeine content 

What I didn’t like;

• Some of the Coffee Frappuccino house drinks are seasonal.  

Who it’s best suited for.

• Best suited for a person who loves coffee lovers and is sweet-toothed. 

Final Verdict: So, Which is Better? – Starbucks Creme Frappuccino or Coffee Frappuccino

The Coffee Frappuccino is better than the Creme Frappuccino. It is so because the former has a rich flavor because it is prepared using the Frappuccino roast, which is a light roast. Additionally, Coffee Frappuccino has relatively high caffeine content, making it ideal for persons looking for a drink to keep them awake or energized. 

FAQ Section

Which is stronger between coffee Frappuccino and crème Frappuccino?

Coffee Frappuccino is stronger since the caffeine levels range from 85 to 155 mg, while crème Frappuccino has 0 to 70 mg depending on the specific drink.

Which is better for weight loss between coffee Frappuccino and crème frappuccino?

Although both coffee Frappuccino and crème Frappuccino are high in sugar and fat, crème Frappuccino is better for weight loss since the drinks have fewer calories on average compared to coffee Frappuccino.

Which one tastes better between coffee Frappuccino and crème Frappuccino?

The taste of the beverages depends on the additions, such as white chocolate, Caramel Ribbon Crunch, vanilla, mocha, or strawberry. Thus, different drinks have different tastes because of the varying flavor, and the better tasting one depends on one’s preference.